Santullo's Eatery: User Reviews

ORDER FROM MY PIE.....BETTER PIZZA and SERVICE!!!!!!!!
By S from s, March 7, 2008

Overall rating:

The staff has a reputation for being rude but tonight takes the cake! We ordered food and the guy who took our order was rude from the get-go and told us we couldn't order more food because he already rung our card. (which is why we didn't cancel) Then the pizza came and was uncooked (which has happened before). When my husband called to let them know they manager hung up on him twice and refused to credit our card OR provide a new pizza. MY PIE is so much better (in Bucktown) and the service is a pleasure! ORDER FROM MY PIE.....BETTER PIZZA!!!!!!!!

Food:

Ambiance:

Service:

Value:

A Wicker Park Must
By jreid4 from Wicker Park, March 5, 2008

Overall rating:

My boyfriend and I always order from Santullo's when we're in the mood for sandwiches; they have some of the best in the city of Chicago. When I am in the restaurant to eat, I love to get the pizza. It's a great slice of New York Style pizza that's almost better than even pizza found in NYC. Definitely recommended to anyone looking for a good selection of custom made pizzas and excellent sandwiches, as well as a great beverage selection (great sodas and beers at reasonable prices).

Food:

Ambiance:

Service:

Value:

This is the real deal for all of you East Coasters who need their NY Style Pies!!
By Brian from South Loop, January 4, 2008

Overall rating:

I saw the recent profile about them on the Metromix show on Comcast and just had to try them out. I'm from Philly so when I heard NYC style pizza I was in. Just got a 20" cheese and it rocks!!! Highly recommend. Next time we'll dine in--we did pick up this first time.

Food:

Ambiance:

Service:

Value:

Great pizza and sandwiches, plus...
By Daisyluc from Chicago, IL, June 22, 2007

Overall rating:

Great pizza and sandwiches, plus a good dessert selection! Really good atmosphere, very homey with great music playing.

try the flat iron bbq...
By Derek from chicago, il, June 21, 2007

Overall rating:

try the flat iron bbq chicken pizza. actually, try all of them!

This place is an incredible...
By Stephanie from Chicago, IL, March 28, 2007

Overall rating:

This place is an incredible find in a sea of new and hip restaurants. This laid back spot boasts delicious pizza, New Yorkers I know would be jealous. The salads are delcious and the service is always helpful. Order a whole pie with a group or just grab a custom made slice. After the bars or out for dinner with friends, this eatery covers all the basics.

Thank god for a normal...
By Al from chicago, IL, November 30, 2006

Overall rating:

Thank god for a normal slice of pizza - I think it's the first one I found in this city. I could fold it - heaven! No sugar sweet sauce, crackery-crust, appetizer-sized mini square, or overgrown casserole style dough bucket! YAY! Also, I just ordered from the counter, so no problem with service.

i highly recommend eating here,...
By Alicia from ukranian Village, il, November 19, 2006

Overall rating:

i highly recommend eating here, but would advise to NEVER put in an order for delivery. The first time we ordered on their online system. They called back to say that they had no delivery driver but we could pick it up. No problem...until we got home to find each of our 3 orders was wrong. We called and they gave us a credit, good only for pizza, even though i hate NY style pizza. Tonight we figured we'd use the credit and called to order a pizza. They were out of our topping choice. We picked another. The guy on the phone was a total jerk. 1 1/2 hours later we have our floppy, cold, and generally crappy pizza. We will NEVER order from there again.

We've order from here twice....
By Julia from Chicago, IL, November 17, 2006

Overall rating:

We've order from here twice. Both times the order that was delivered was completely wrong, and delivery was slow. The restaurant refused to give me a credit for the food that wasn't delivered in the second order and insisted on bringing the missing items later, so I got my salad and desert after dinner. Thanks a bunch.