'Eagle Eye' review

And you thought "Live Free or Die Hard" turned real issues into rubbish

By Matt Pais

Metromix
September 25, 2008

 
Critic's Rating:
2 1/2

'Eagle Eye' review
Photos:
Poster Art. Shia LaBeouf as Jerry Shaw and Michelle Monaghan as Rachel Holloman in "Eagle Eye." Shia LaBeouf as Jerry Shaw and Michelle Monaghan as Rachel Holloman in "Eagle Eye." Shia LaBeouf as Jerry Shaw and Michelle Monaghan as Rachel Holloman in "Eagle Eye."
Eagle Eye
Running time:
118 minutes
Rated:
PG-13
Cast:
Shia LaBeouf -
Jerry Shaw
Michelle Monaghan -
Rachel Holloman
Rosario Dawson -
Zoe
Michael Chiklis -
Callister
Anthony Mackie -
Scott
See full cast
Director:
D.J. Caruso
Genre:
Action
Official Movie Web Site:
http://www.eagleeyemovie.com/
Overall User Rating:
3 1/2 (15 ratings)
Write a review

One minute Jerry (Shia LaBeouf) is an innocent copy boy mourning the loss of his twin brother, the next his apartment is filled with weapons, he receives mysterious phone calls and must obey all wild instructions under penalty of death. He’s got help in Rachel (Michelle Monaghan), who’s being similarly manipulated by constant surveillance and threats that her son will be harmed. Billy Bob Thornton stars as an agent who thinks Jerry’s a terrorist and Michael Chiklis plays the U.S. defense secretary, the lone dissenting voice as high-ranking officials approve an attack when they’re not even sure of the target’s identity.

Big question: Can "Eagle Eye" capitalize on the not-so-fresh fear of government intrusion while director D.J. Caruso (“Disturbia”) helps LaBeouf work towards being the next big action hero?

Skip it: “Eagle Eye” is as convoluted as the booby traps in the “Saw” movies and likewise mistaken about the moral issues being explored in its technology-based mess. The worst-case-scenario story gets off to a good, nervous start, but as the absurdity mounts unintentional laughs replace excitement and remind us that action movies need decent scripts too.

Catch it: For tips on how to treat your significant other right, as Jerry advises that you need to take them somewhere classy like Red Lobster or Olive Garden. That is, if you can’t get a reservation at Friday’s.

Bottom line: The movie's slick, the actors are strong and there are a handful of action sequences that really keep their foot on the gas, even as the vehicle spins out of control. While "Eagle Eye" is fine if you willfully ignore its many real problems, that’s not really a way to watch a movie and especially questionable in the context of terrorism and national security.

Bonus:
Defense Secretary Callister (Chiklis) insists that “37 percent” and “probable” don’t belong in the same sentence. Good to know the government is out to prevent the nation’s weather forecasters from issuing any foolishly confident predictions.

Video: Watch the review of 'Eagle Eye'

What other people are saying...

No-pic-dude

Hollywould from St. Louis - October 11, 2008 at 3:51 AM

great i was going to go see it but now i dont know. Its hard for me ignore flaws in movies, and actually bothers me so thank you and good comments

Report This Comment
No-pic-chick

Roosh from California - October 07, 2008 at 11:48 AM

****SPOILER**** What I thought was interesting was the premise regarding a computer taking the Constitution literally.

Report This Comment
No-pic-dude

greenman from twin cities - October 03, 2008 at 4:51 PM

I don't entirely disagree with your review, however, I don't think its a good idea to tell the viewers how to watch a movie. You stated willfully...

More...

Report This Comment
No-pic-dude

normen from manila - October 01, 2008 at 10:17 AM

Great action nail boting suspense...DJ Caruso has did an excellent jod as an action director

Report This Comment
No-pic-dude

moviebuff from manchester - September 26, 2008 at 2:54 PM

I thought it was a pretty good film. I think adventure is adventure and they brought the AI side of things into government intrusion. Essential G...

More...

Report This Comment

Add a comment

You will be prompted to register or log in when posting.

Please note that by clicking on "Post Comment" you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator.

SHOWTIME LISTINGS

Movie theaters and showtimes for Eagle Eye in Chicago.

Narrow search by zipcode:

Check Showtimes for Eagle Eye

Showtimes for Today, December 05

CC Ogden 6 Theatre
1227 E. Ogden Ave. - Naperville, IL 60563
Friday, December 5
2:00 | 4:30 | 7:00 | 9:30
Marcus Gurnee Cinema
6144 Grand Ave. - Gurnee, IL 60031
Friday, December 5
11:30 | 2:10 | 4:50

VIDEO

Movie reviews

Movie reviews

Catch up on recent film reviews you might have missed the first time around.