Home > Chicago Movies > Movie Review > Dan in Real Life

Advice columnist Dan Burns (Steve Carell)—a widower raising three girls—unexpectedly finds love during a weekend getaway with his extended family. Unfortunately the woman of his dreams (Juliette Binoche) is also his brother’s (Dane Cook) new girlfriend.

Big questions: Can Carell recover from the disastrous “Evan Almighty”? And, less pressing but still worth pondering, will Cook ever make a good movie?

Skip it: Although it looks promising on paper—with Carell in a role that allows him to balance drama, comedy and romance unlike anything he’s done before, and an inspired choice of leading lady in the Oscar-winning Binoche—“Dan in Real Life” winds up a modest disappointment. The undernourished and overly conventional screenplay explores a potentially complicated situation with all the emotional authenticity of a Lifetime movie. And despite Carell’s best efforts, there’s no disguising the fact that we’re never allowed more than a shallow view of who Dan really is.

Catch it: For yet another one of Carell's patented crazy white guy dances. His smooth moves steal the show.

Bottom line: Instead of building a solid foundation for his capable leads, director Peter Hedges (who also co-scripted with Pierce Gardner) overloads his film with characters and then gives them nothing interesting to do. The end result resembles a slightly warmer version of “The Family Stone” with crossword puzzle contests, talent shows and group aerobics substituting for fleshed-out characters.

Bonus: Cook demonstrates yet another talent he doesn’t have when his character “sings” Pete Townsend’s “Let My Love Open the Door.” At least in this case he’s supposed to be bad.

Add a comment